The Rules of Engagement

How It Works

Debatism is designed to foster real intellectual discourse. Every rule exists to ensure the best arguments rise to the top.

Core Rules

👁

Browse Without Signing In

All public debates are viewable without an account. Read arguments, see vote tallies, and explore the platform. You only need to sign in when you're ready to participate by voting, posting arguments, or switching sides.

Requires Sign In:

Voting • Posting Arguments • Switching Sides • Creating Debates

1

Choose a Side

Every participant must declare For or Against before posting or voting. This commitment ensures everyone has skin in the game and prevents fence-sitting.

For
Against
2

Side-Aligned Voting

Each participant receives exactly 6 votes per debate - 3 positive and 3 negative. Your relationship to an argument determines which votes you can use:

The Rule

  • Your side's arguments: Use positive OR negative votes
  • Opposing side's arguments: Negative votes ONLY

Positive Votes

Your side only

  • High Impact+20 pts
  • Medium Impact+10 pts
  • Low Impact+2 pts

Negative Votes

Any argument

  • High Impact-10 pts
  • Medium Impact-5 pts
  • Low Impact-1 pt

Votes are locked for 7 days before they can be moved to another argument.

3

Switch Sides

Changed your mind? You can switch sides up to 3 times during a debate, with increasing time constraints between switches. This powerful mechanic rewards truly persuasive arguments.

When You Switch

  • 🎯Select the convincing argument — it receives a +25 persuasion bonus
  • ❄️Your old votes are frozen — they still count, but cannot be moved
  • You get 6 fresh votes — a new set for your new side

1st Switch

After 1 week

2nd Switch

After 1 month

3rd Switch

After 1 year

Arguments that change minds earn a "🎯 Changed X minds" badge — the highest honor on the platform.

4

Argument Structure

Every argument must be substantive. We enforce quality through word minimums and AI checks.

Top-Level Arguments

Minimum 15 words. Up to 3 per side per user.

Counter-Arguments

Minimum 15 words. One per depth level.

Arguments are checked for: substantive content, on-topic relevance, and coherent reasoning. Maximum nesting depth: 4 levels (argument → counter → counter → counter).

View Modes

#1

Top

Arguments ranked by total score. The cream rises to the top.

Trending

Arguments gaining momentum in the last 24 hours. Hot takes welcome.

Newest

Fresh perspectives. Hidden if score drops below -10.

For You

AI-powered semantic matching based on your expressed views.

My Votes

Filter to only show arguments you've voted on. Track your vote placements and when they become moveable.

Performance Bonuses

Outstanding arguments receive bonus points through two mechanisms:

Persuasion Bonus

When someone switches sides and selects your argument as the one that convinced them:

+25 points

🎯 Badge displayed

Top 3 Per Side

After 72 hours, the three highest-scoring arguments on each side receive:

+5 points

🏅 Medal displayed

Most Persuasive

After 72 hours, the argument with the most mind-changes receives:

+10 points

🏆 Trophy displayed

In case of ties for system bonuses, the earliest-created argument wins.

Debate Resolution

Debates can be configured with a judging date to determine a winner after a set timeframe. This creates a sense of urgency and allows debates to reach formal conclusions.

Countdown Phase

Before the judging date, a countdown banner shows time remaining. Participants compete to build the strongest case before time runs out.

🏆

Judging & Results

When the date arrives, the debate is automatically judged based on total argument scores. Results are immutable and permanently recorded.

How Winners Are Determined

  1. 1.All argument scores on each side are summed (positive votes - negative votes)
  2. 2.The side with the higher total score wins
  3. 3.Results include: winning side, final scores, margin of victory
  4. 4.Equal scores result in a tie

Open-Ended Debates

Not all debates need a judging date. Debates without one remain open indefinitely, allowing for ongoing discourse without a time constraint.

Reputation System

Your reputation points reflect your contributions to quality discourse. Points unlock platform features and signal your experience level.

🎓 Advocate Status

Reach 500 reputation points to unlock Advocate status and gain the ability to create new debates.

Advocate Perks:

Create Debates • Trusted Contributor Badge • Reduced Rate Limits

💎 How to Earn Points

  • +5Post an argument (top-level or counter-argument)
  • +2 to +20Receive upvotes on your arguments
  • +100Change someone's mind (they switch sides and credit your argument)
  • -1 to -10Receive downvotes on your arguments

Track Your Progress

View your reputation breakdown and recent activity in your Settings > Reputation page. Your reputation points are displayed in the header, showing your progress toward Advocate status.

Leaderboards

Per-Debate Rankings

Each debate shows two leaderboards recognizing the most impactful contributors:

Top Contributors

Ranked by total argument score - the sum of all votes received on their arguments in this debate.

Mind Changers

Ranked by minds changed - how many people switched sides after reading their arguments.

Privacy Control

You can opt out of appearing on leaderboards via Settings. Your contributions still count, but your name won't appear in public rankings.

How Scores Are Calculated

Your leaderboard position is based on the quality and persuasiveness of your arguments:

  • Positive votes (+20, +10, +2) add to your score
  • Negative votes (-10, -5, -1) subtract from your score
  • Mind changes count when someone selects your argument as the reason they switched sides (+25 persuasion bonus)

Only your arguments in that specific debate count toward that debate's leaderboard. Platform-wide leaderboards are coming in a future update.

Source Reliability

Arguments can include up to 5 source URLs. Each source is validated and labeled:

✓ Least Biased← Left-Center→ Right-Center! Conspiracy😄 Satire

We don't censor sources - all are allowed, just labeled. Powered by Media Bias/Fact Check.

Trust & Safety

Flagging System

Flag arguments as: Factually Incorrect, Misleading, Off-Topic, or Low Quality.

Rate limit: 2 flags per debate per 24h. Flag accuracy affects your reputation.

Edit Restrictions

Arguments are locked once they receive any vote. This prevents bait-and-switch tactics.

AI Moderation

Harmful content screening, semantic duplicate detection, and quality checks on every submission.

Privacy Options

Go anonymous and appear as "Former User" while your arguments remain attributed.

21 Categories

🏛️Politics & Government🔬Science & Technology🌍Environment & Climate💼Economics & Business⚕️Health & Medicine🤔Philosophy & Ethics⚖️Law & Justice🤝Social Issues📚Education🎭Culture & Society🕊️Religion & Spirituality🧠Psychology🌐International Relations🏙️Urban Planning🌾Food & Agriculture📡Media & Communication🎨Arts & EntertainmentSports & Recreation📜History🔮Future & Speculation🎉Fun

Ready to Join?

Now that you understand the rules, it's time to pick a side and make your case.